Categories
Science

Reactions to "The Blank Slate" (Part Two)

Some really interesting stuff in Steven Pinker’s The Blank Slate about responsibility, free will and guilt:

“When we say that we hold someone responsible for a wrongful act, we expect him to punish himself – by compensating the victim, acquiescing to humiliation, incurring penalties, or expressing credible remorse – and we reserve the right to punish him ourselves. Unless a person is willing to suffer some unpleasant (and hence deterring) consequence, claims of responsibility are hollow. Richard Nixon was ridiculed when he bowed to pressure and finally “took responsibility” for the Watergate burglary but did not accept any costs such as apologizing, resigning, or firing his aides.”

Categories
Random

Trivial entertainment links…

Here’s a snapshot of what the rest of the world looks like when you’ve just returned from Helsinki:

Categories
Random

Frustrated after Helsinki…

So I’m back in the UK after the Aula MOM 2003 event and I’m feeling a bit flat. I was talking about “The Mass Amateurisation of (Nearly) Everything”, which is kind of an old thing of mine that I’ve never really written about properly. It’s directly inspired by Clay’s Weblogs and the Mass Amateurization of Publishing and indirectly insired by Dan Hill’s thoughts on Adaptive Design. I was on a kind-of-panel with Matt Jones and Dan Gillmor. Fun new people I met (alongside the whole awesome Aula crew) included the terrifyingly uber-connected Joi Ito, the insightful JC Herz and the charming Eric Wahlforss. And it was nice, as ever, to bump into Cory.

So why do I feel flat? I don’t know – I suppose a variety of reasons. I didn’t feel comfortable with the way I presented my piece, I guess. Or maybe I didn’t feel comfortable with the way I presented myself. Maybe I was unsure with the contribution I made generally. I don’t know. People said really interesting things, really interesting people said really interesting things. But I felt a bit … I don’t know … Unconnected? Unproductive? Maybe I’ll feel better after a good night’s sleep…

Categories
Random

A small request to Six Apart…

So here’s a tiny thing that I’d be really interested in seeing in a subsequent version of Movable Type. It’s so small it’s barely worth mentioning – particularly as the proper search function has now been integrated. But nonetheless it would make my life slightly more simple.

When I’m editing an entry, I’d just like a link that would take me to the current live version of that post. That’s all. Just a link which would allow me to bounce out of my MT installation to see what it looks like live, without having to battle to find it amid nearly four-years of almost-daily posting… Obviously, this is also an indictment of the terrible way I currently have my search engine configured. But I just think it could be useful and it should be pretty easy, I think…

Categories
Random

A pier into the sea…

A pier at a business retreat near Helsinki.

Categories
Technology

Cameras communicating with Cameras…

So here’s a dumb idea about digital cameras. Let’s imagine a world in which everyone has a camera – and they carry them with them all the time. Say – for example – that they’re built into mobile phones. Right. Now you add in a sensor to each camera that means that they can communicate with all cameras within a narrowly focused area that corresponds with the area about to be captured within the viewfinder. Right. Now every camera includes information about how the person who owns it “feels” about various uses of their images. They can say, “I don’t feel comfortable with you distributing this image to your friends” or “Don’t take pictures of me” or whatever. Maybe even “no close-ups”. This information is thrown out to any camera that tries to take a picture of you and this has an influence on how the picture can be easily used.

So – for example – if I were a private nervous person who didn’t want photos taken of me at all, then I could set my camera to a ‘leave me alone’ mode. If someone tried to take a picture of me on a “normal” setting, then they’d find that their camera simply wouldn’t work. They’d keep pressing the button, but would be presented with error beeps instead. They’d have to actually switch to a “rude” mode in order to be able to take a photo. And if you didn’t want it to be distributed, the phone would just stop you forwarding it to other people – again unless you were prepared to switch into a “rude” mode. Could be fun…

Categories
Random

Helsinki at midnight…

helsinki_at_midnight.jpg

Caption: Helsinki at midnight. Currently: Nervous about Aula Meeting of Minds 2003.

Categories
Random

The Ten Commandments of Weblogging…

Being a feeble transcription of some things that seemed really funny once over lunch with Cal, and which we tried – and failed – to get Webb interested in.

The Ten Commandments of Weblogging

  1. I am the log of the web. You shall have no other blogs but me.
  2. You shall not make for yourself other weblogs on other content management systems and look at them and get all wistful and think about changing to them instead.
  3. You shall not mention dodgy weblog CMSs in the same breath as proper ones like Blogger and Moveable Type. Bloxsom is not a proper weblogging system. It’s a potato.
  4. Remember the Bloggie nomination day. For it is truly a holy day and if you don’t remember and self-nominate and vote for yourself lots of times and get your friends to do so too, then you’re probably screwed. But be careful, ‘cos if Choire finds out you’re in serious shit.
  5. Honor your blog-father and your blog-mother at blogtree.com – or get blog-smacked-around-the-head by Dave Winer.
  6. You shall not murder the English language (or whatever language it is you speak) just because you’re l33t. Particularly not if you’re a teenager. Especially not if you like Linkin Park.
  7. Thou shalt not commit weblog-adultery with other people’s hard-earned links unless you carefully mark them with a “via” credit. The same applies to their girlfriends, boyfriends and members of their immediate family.
  8. Thou shalt not steal your design (except from Kottke).
  9. Thou shalt not lie on your weblog (seriously, that’s bad).
  10. You shall not covet your neighbour’s domain; you shall not covet your neighbour’s html, nor his homemade CMS, nor his hosting arrangement, nor anything that is your neighbour’s. Except maybe his traffic.
Categories
Politics

On rapid constitutional change…

Beat this Americans… 1,400 years after the post was first created, the role of the Lord Chancellor in the UK has been abolished. And, for the first time in hundreds of years, the political establishment and the judiciary have been forcibly separated from one another. This – obviously – is a tremendous move and almost certainly a positive one. My only anxiety is the speed of the shift and the way it doesn’t really appear to have been the result of any public debate. We will soon have a supreme court. Who knew? [Thanks to Michael for the link]

   Tony Blair revealed a renewed thirst for radical constitutional reform yesterday when he swept aside 1,400 years of history by abolishing the post of lord chancellor and setting up a new US-style supreme court in place of the law lords.
   The prime minister will also set up an independent judicial appointments commission, a reform resisted until very recently by Derry Irvine, who quit the government yesterday after six years.
   The reforms, the product of a long Whitehall battle, bring about the much-demanded separation of powers between the judiciary and politicians.

I’m really interested in a debate about this subject – is it a good thing or a bad thing? Is it being pushed through? Where’s the debate?

Categories
Random

Burning the name of god…

So there’s a guy outside the back of my flat who has lit a bonfire against the back wall of my building. The flames are licking up the wall. There is a large empty courtyard behind him. But no – the bonfire obviously has to be lit on the building. I asked him what he was doing with the whole “lighting a big fire against my building” thing. He evidently thought I was reacting entirely strangely about his completely legitimate arson attempts because he looked quite surprised by my question. Maybe he’s been setting fire to things for about ten years and no one in England has felt able to comment before. “I’m sure he’ll go away eventually dear… Just grin and bear it, eh?”

So anyway, it turns out he’s trying to getting rid of paper “with the name of god on it” and didn’t want to be disrespectful by putting it in the bin. He thought he’d best light the bonfire against my building (flames licking up the wall) during the day, “because [he] didn’t think people would be at home”, so clearly it would be less inconvenient for them. Unless of course they got home and they didn’t – you know – have a flat any more. I was terribly polite. I asked him if he knew what he was doing, he asserted he did. I looked a bit uncomfortable, but I didn’t want to be rude. So I came back inside and left him to it. Funny old world.